Choosing the right contraceptive pill

Dr Aajuli Shukla

writer

Dr Aajuli Shukla

General Practitioner; Deputy Medical Editor, Medical Journal of Australia; Member of the Editorial Advisory Board for the Diabetes Management Journal

Dr Aajuli Shukla

There’s a dazzling array of choice.

At some point, most GPs will be asked to prescribe the oral contraceptive pill for a patient. It’s important to consider the pros and cons of each type of pill as well as the patient’s unique situation before deciding on which one is most suitable for them.

As reproductive health clinician Dr Deborah Bateson pointed out in a recent Women’s and Children’s health podcast, many women present with preconceived ideas about which pill is best based on their own experience or that of a family member or a friend. It is important to consider and manage these ideas and expectations regarding the pill as part of the pre-prescribing assessment.

When advising patients on the most appropriate pill for them, there are several factors to consider.

Firstly, do they need a combined pill or would the progesterone only pill be more suitable? The progestogen only pill tends to have fewer contraindications than the combined oral contraceptive pill and can be used in females who have migraines with aura and those that smoke over the age of 35.

The combined oral contraceptive can also be useful in managing acne and heavy menstruation in addition to its contraception use whereas the progestogen only pill carries with it a risk of irregular bleeding – so a woman’s lifestyle is an important consideration. A history of breast cancer often precludes the use of either form of hormonal contraception.

A thorough and comprehensive history is important to assess a patient’s risk factors prior to prescribing the pill, either progestogen only or the combination form.

Dr Bateson pointed to the UK Faculty of Sexual and Reproductive health MEC guide that is freely available online that can help guide that decision. It is useful in determining the appropriateness of contraceptive use via an easy grading system of 1-4 with 1 indicating no issues in using that form of contraceptive and 4 indicating an absolute contraindication.

Once, it has been determined that the combined oral contraceptive pill is suitable for a patient, the next decision will be which particular combination and dose should be recommended.

While certain formulations might be used for acne, for example, a good starting point is to use a pill with levonorgestrel and 30 micrograms of ethinyloestradiol as they tend to be the gold standard in terms of effectiveness, risk profile and affordability (as they are listed on the PBS).

Recommending a contraceptive pill to a patient might be daunting with regards to the number of options available but this podcast helps establish some guiding principles that take the patient’s unique factors into account.

This podcast collates information from a survey involving 1,000 GPs and answers the most common contraceptive pill-based questions.

An Oral Contraception Update will be provided by sexual health physician Prof Deborah Bateson at the upcoming Healthed webcast on 16 August. Don’t miss the next free fortnightly webcast, register here.

Icon 2

NEXT LIVE Webcast

:
Days
:
Hours
:
Minutes
Seconds
Prof Andrew Sindone

Prof Andrew Sindone

An Update on Heart Failure in Primary Care

Dr Gabby Mahoney

Dr Gabby Mahoney

Allergen Introduction – Practical Tips for GPs

Prof Kim Delbaere

Prof Kim Delbaere

Falls Prevention – A Practical, Evidence-Based Update on What Really Works

Dr Stephanie Daly

Dr Stephanie Daly

The New Dementia Test and How they Fit Into the Assessment and Management of the Patient with Cognitive Concerns

Join us for the next free webcast for GPs and healthcare professionals

High quality lectures delivered by leading independent experts

Share this

Share this

Dr Aajuli Shukla

writer

Dr Aajuli Shukla

General Practitioner; Deputy Medical Editor, Medical Journal of Australia; Member of the Editorial Advisory Board for the Diabetes Management Journal

Test your knowledge

Recent articles

Latest GP poll

The government told the public that the average GP is earning $280k per year. Do you think this figure is:

Very overestimated

0%

Moderately/slightly overestimated

0%

Quite accurate

0%

Moderately/slightly underestimated

0%

Very underestimated

0%

Recent podcasts

Listen to expert interviews.
Click to open in a new tab

Find your area of interest

Once you confirm you’ve read this article you can complete a Patient Case Review to earn 0.5 hours CPD in the Reviewing Performance (RP) category.

Select ‘Confirm & learn‘ when you have read this article in its entirety and you will be taken to begin your Patient Case Review.

First Healthed Webcast for 2026

An Update on Heart Failure in Primary Care

Tuesday 3rd February, 7pm - 9pm AEDT

Speaker

Prof Andrew Sindone

Cardiologist; Director of the Heart Failure Unit and Department of Cardiac Rehabilitation, Concord Hospital

We invite you to our first webcast of 2026, where Prof Andrew Sindone will provide an update on heart failure in primary care. Earn up to 4 hours CPD. RACGP & ACRRM accredited.